The Lazy Blog

Utopia for Realist

Utopia for Realist and How we can get there - Rutger Bregman

A map of the world that does not include Utopia is not worth even glancing at, for it leaves out the one country at which Humanity is always landing. And when Humanity lands there, it looks out, and, seeing a better country, set sail. Progress is the realization of Utopias. - Oscar Wilde (1854 - 1900)

And it understands that, as Voltaire put it, the perfect is the enemy of good. As one American philosopher has remarked, “any serious utopian thinker will be made uncomfortable by the very idea of the blueprint.”

“The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click ads,” a formed math whiz at Facebook recently lamented.

Lest there be any misunderstanding: It is capitalism that opened the gates to the Land of Plenty, but capitalism alone cannot sustain it.

“Povery is fundamentally about a lack of cash. It’s not about stupidity,” stresses the economist Joseph Hanlon. “You can’t pull yourself up by your bootsraps if you have no boots.”

Just a few years ago, the prestigious medical journal the Lancet summed up their findings: When the poor receive no-strings cash they actually tend to work harder.

Not until 1978 was the plan for a basic income shelved once and for all, however, following a fatal discovery upon publication of the final results of the Seattle experiment. The number of divorces had jumped more than 50%. Interest in this statistic qucikly oversahdowed all the other outcomes, such as better school performance and improvements in health. A basic income, evidently, gave women too much independence.

Ten years later, a reanalysis of the data revealed taht a statistical error had been made; in reality, there had been no change in the divorce rate at all.

The great milestones of civilization always have the whiff of utopia about them at first. According to renowned sociologist Albert Hirschman, utopias are initially attacked on three grounds: futility (it’s not possible), danger (the risks are too great), and perversity (it will degenerate into dystopia). But Hirschman also wrote that almost as soon as a utopia beomces a reality, it often comes to be seen as utterly commonplace. Not so very long ago, democracy still seemed a glorious utopia. Many a great mind, from the philosopher Plato (427 - 347 B.C.) to the statesman Edmund Burke (1729 - 97), warned that democracy was futile (the masses were be akin to playing with fire), and perverse (the “general interest” would soon be corrupted by the interests of some crafty general or other). Compare this with the arguments against basic income. It’s supposedly futile because we can’t pay for it, dangerous because people would quit working, and perverse because ultimately a minority would end up having to toil harder to support the majority.

Despite all this, the drawbacks of a “scarcity mentality” are greater than the benefits. Sacrcity narrows your focus to your immediate lack, to the meeting that’s starting in five minutes or the bills that need to be paid tomorrow. The long-term perspective goes out the window. “Scarcity consumes you,” Shafir explains. “You’re less able to focus on other things that are also important to you.”

There’s a key distinction though between people with busy lives and those living in poverty: You can’t take a break from poverty.

Whether you look at the incidenc of depression, childhoods, low election turnout, or social and political distrust, the evidence points to the same culprit every time: inequality.

“The past is a foreign country,” a novelist once wrote: “they do things differently there.”

In his 1786 Dissertation on the Poor Laws, the vicar Joseph Townsend had already, almost a decade before Speenhamland, warned that “it is only hunger which can spur and goad them on to labour; yet our laws have said, they shall never hunger.”

The investigators behind this Royal Commission survey blamed the basic income for a population explosion, wage reductions, increased immoral conduct – effectively, for the utter deterioration of the English working class. Fortunately, though, no sooner had the basic income been repealed, they wrote, than:

  1. The poor once more became industrious.
  2. They developed “frugal habits.”
  3. “Demand for their labour” increased.
  4. Their wages “in general advanced.”
  5. They entered into fewer “improvident and wretched marriages.”
  6. Their “moral and social condition in every way improved.”

In the 1960s and 1970s, historians took another look at the Royal Commission Report on Speenhamland and discovered that much of the text had been written before any data was even collected. Of the questionnaires distributed, only 10% were ever filled out. Furthermore, the questions were leading, with the answer choices all fixed in advance. And almost none of the people interviewed were actual beneficiaries. The evidence, such as it was, came mostly from the local elite, and especially the clergy, whose general view was that the poor were only growing more wicked and lazy.

Threshers, which literally helped separate the wheat from the chaff, destroyed thousands of jobs in one fell swoop, thereby depressing wages and inflating the cost of poor relief.

All the while, the steady upward trend of agricultural production never faltered, increasing by a third between 1790 and 1830. Food was more plentiful than ever, yet a decreasing share of the English population could afford it. Not because they were lazy, but because they were losing the race against the machine.

The gross national product . . . measures everything . . . except that which makes life worthwhile. - Robert F. Kennedy (1925–68)

“If banking had been eliminated from the GDP, rather than added to it,” the Financial Times recently reported, “it is plausible to speculate that the financial crisis would never have happened.”

We live in a world where the going rate seems to be that the more vital your occupation (cleaning, nursing, teaching), the lower your rank in the GDP.

Instead of creating wealth, these jobs mostly just shift it.

Bizarrely, it’s precisely the jobs that shift money around – creating next to nothing of tangible value – that net the best salaries. It’s a fascinating, paradoxical state of affairs. How is it possible that all those agents of prosperity – the teachers, the police officers, the nurses – are paid so poorly, while the unimportant, superfluous, and even destructive shifters do so well?

Work? That was for peasants.

The British economist Guy Standing has predicted the emergence of a new, dangerous “precariat” – a surging social class of people in low-wage, temporary jobs and with no political voice.

These are researchers who have had enough of the intuition, gut feelings, and ideological bickering of ivory-tower scholars about the needs of people struggling in Africa and elsewhere. What the randomistas want is numbers – incontrovertible data to show which aid helps and which doesn’t.

To Easterly, it was obvious where all this was heading. Sachs and his buddy Bono would organize a charity concert, rake in a couple million, and then drop thousands of mosquito nets over Africa. In no time, the local net retailers would all be out of business, while the surfeit of nets would soon be doing duty as fishing gear or wedding veils. A few years after Sachs the Redeemer’s campaign, when the gift nets had worn out, the number of children dying of malaria would be higher than ever.

“People do not get used to handouts,” Duflo succinctly points out. “They get used to nets.”

Microcredit’s reckoning came in the form of our old friend Esther Duflo, who set up a fat RCT in Hyderabad, India, and demonstrated that, all the heartwarming anecdotes notwithstanding, there is no hard evidence that microcredit is effective at combating poverty and illness. Handing out cash works way better. As it happens, cash handouts may be the most extensively studied anti-poverty method around. RCTs across the globe have shown that over both the long and short term and on both a large and small scale, cash transfers are an extremely successful and efficient tool.

“[T]he U.S. border effect on the wages of equal intrinsic productivity workers is greater than any form of wage discrimination (gender, race, or ethnicity) that has ever been measured,” observe three economists. It’s apartheid on a global scale. In the twenty-first century, the real elite are those born not in the right family or the right class but in the right country. Yet this modern elite is scarcely aware of how lucky it is.

“A man with a conviction is a hard man to change,” so opens Leon Festinger’s account of these events in When Prophecy Fails, first published in 1956 and a seminal text in social psychology to this day. “Tell him you disagree and he turns away,” Festinger continues. “Show him facts or figures and he questions your sources. Appeal to logic and he fails to see your point.”

It’s easy to scoff at the story of Mrs. Martin and her believers, but the phenomenon Festinger describes is one that none of us is immune to: “Cognitive dissonance,” he termed it. When reality clashes with our deepest convictions, we’d rather recalibrate reality than amend our worldview. Not only that, we become even more rigid in our beliefs than before.

Mind you, we tend to be quite flexible when it comes to practical matters. Most of us are even willing to accept advice on how to remove a grease stain or chop a cucumber. No, it’s when our political, ideological, or religious ideas are at stake that we get the most stubborn. We tend to dig in our heels when someone challenges our opinions about criminal punishment, premarital sex, or global warming. These are ideas to which people tend to get attached, and that makes it difficult to let them go. Doing so affects our sense of identity and position in social groups – in our churches or families or circles of friends.

Smart people, concludes the American journalist Ezra Klein, don’t use their intellect to obtain the correct answer; they use it to obtain what they want to be the answer.